If you have started looking into trauma therapy, two names come up again and again: EMDR and cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT). Both are well researched. Both can help. But they work differently and feel different in the room, and knowing that can make it easier to choose. This guide explains how EMDR works, how trauma-focused CBT works, who each tends to help, and how to decide.
Call (949) 259-5123 See same-week openings
In crisis or thinking of harming yourself? Call or text 988, or dial 911. We are an outpatient practice, not an emergency service. More options are on our crisis resources page.
New to EMDR? Our article Can EMDR therapy help you process traumatic memories? covers the basics, including what a session feels like and common myths. This piece focuses on comparing EMDR with CBT.
What both have in common
EMDR and trauma-focused CBT are both structured, time-limited therapies that work directly with the effects of trauma rather than only talking around them. The World Health Organization and the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs and Department of Defense clinical practice guideline both list EMDR and trauma-focused CBT approaches, such as cognitive processing therapy and prolonged exposure, among recommended treatments for PTSD. Both start with getting to know you and building stability, and both aim for the same result: memories that feel like the past instead of the present.
How EMDR works
EMDR stands for eye movement desensitization and reprocessing. The theory is that an overwhelming experience can be stored with its original fear, sounds and body sensations still attached, which is why a smell or tone of voice can trigger a reaction years later.
In EMDR, you briefly bring part of a memory to mind while following bilateral stimulation, usually side-to-side eye movements, alternating taps or tones. After each short set, you notice what comes up and keep going. Over time, many people find the memory becomes less vivid and less upsetting, and a more balanced belief, such as “I survived” or “it wasn’t my fault,” starts to feel true.
A few features stand out:
- You don’t have to describe the memory in detail out loud.
- There is usually little or no homework between sessions.
- Therapy follows eight phases, including preparation, so you learn calming skills before any processing begins.
How trauma-focused CBT works
Cognitive behavioral therapy looks at the link between thoughts, feelings and behavior. Trauma-focused versions include:
- Cognitive processing therapy (CPT), which helps you identify and question “stuck points,” beliefs like “I should have stopped it” or “the world is completely unsafe.”
- Prolonged exposure (PE), which gradually and safely helps you approach memories and situations you have been avoiding, so fear can decrease.
- General CBT skills for sleep, panic, avoidance and self-talk.
CBT tends to be more conversational and skills-based. It usually includes practice between sessions, such as worksheets, writing or gradually facing avoided situations.
Who each approach tends to suit
There is no rule that matches a person to a therapy, and a good therapist will talk it through with you. In general:
EMDR may appeal if you
- Find it very hard to put the experience into words, or don’t want to retell it in detail
- Understand your story intellectually, but your body still reacts as if it is happening now
- Have specific memories, such as an accident, assault or medical emergency, that keep intruding
- Prefer less homework
CBT may appeal if you
- Like structure, worksheets and clear skills you can practice
- Are stuck in beliefs about blame, shame or safety
- Have a lot of avoidance in daily life you want to tackle step by step
- Also want help with panic, sleep or anxious thinking
For long-standing or childhood trauma, either approach may spend more time on stabilization first. If dissociation is part of your history, tell your therapist at the start so they can pace the work safely.
Can you combine them?
Yes, and many therapists do. Someone might learn CBT skills for sleep and panic, then use EMDR for a specific memory. Body-based (somatic) techniques can help both by calming the nervous system. If nightmares, poor sleep or constant tension make it hard to engage, a psychiatric evaluation with a nurse practitioner can be added, and our PTSD treatment page explains how therapy and psychiatric care work together.
EMDR and CBT at IPW Health
According to our team bios, two licensed therapists include EMDR in their work:
- Leila Hashemi, LCSW, combines CBT, EMDR and somatic-based techniques for anxiety, depression, trauma, stress and life transitions. She speaks English and Farsi.
- Maria Rheba Estante, LMFT, LPCC, is an EMDR Consultant-in-Training who also uses exposure and response prevention (ERP), acceptance and commitment therapy (ACT) and Brainspotting, for adults with PTSD, anxiety, OCD, panic and phobias, depression and grief.
Therapy is offered by secure video to clients located in California. Both EMDR and CBT work well by telehealth: eye movements can be guided on screen, or you can use self-tapping. We are in network with Aetna, Anthem, Blue Cross Blue Shield, Cigna, Medicare, Optum and UnitedHealthcare, and self-pay therapy ranges from $140 to $250 per session (see plans and pricing). Learn more on our EMDR and trauma therapy page.
Frequently asked questions
Is EMDR better than CBT for trauma?
Neither is better for everyone. Major guidelines list both EMDR and trauma-focused CBT among recommended treatments for PTSD. The best choice depends on your history, your preferences and how you like to work.
Do I have to talk about my trauma in EMDR?
You will share enough for your therapist to understand what you are working on, but EMDR does not require you to describe the memory in detail out loud.
Does CBT for trauma involve homework?
Usually, yes. Trauma-focused CBT often includes practice between sessions, such as worksheets, writing or gradually facing situations you have been avoiding. EMDR typically involves less homework.
Can EMDR and CBT be done by telehealth?
Yes. Both work by secure video. For EMDR, eye movements can be guided on screen or you can use self-tapping. At IPW Health, therapy is offered to clients located in California.
Talk with a trauma therapist
Call (949) 259-5123 and we will help you choose between EMDR, CBT or a mix, and match you with the right therapist.
